2GuysTalking Television Review Blogs

Scrubs: My Musical

January 20th, 2007 by bigorangemichael

At long last, we finally see the musical episode of Scrubs.

At the risk of sounding like a Joss Whedon groupie–Buffy‘s musical episode was better.

I really had to work to turn off the analytical side of my mind that immediately began comparing to the two episodes.  I tried to enjoy the musical episode for what it was worth, but time and again, the genius that was the Buffy musical kept coming up in my mind.  And how desparately Scrubs wanted to emulate that — and wasn’t.


Buffy‘s musical found a spell cast upon the town that forced characters to express deep, internal desires and thoughts in song.   So, the central conceit of a many musicals that characters will say things in song and dance they wouldn’t in ordinary conversation had a legitimate, well-established reason.  Also, the point at which all the characters were, such revelations were needed to propel the season’s storyline.

Scrubs tries to do the same thing.  Only this time it’s a patient who due to an anuryism is hearing everyone sing.  Some of the songs reveal things about the internal monologue of the characters, but then you’ve got the song about poo that ruins that whole idea.  The big issue was that it felt like Scrubs was trying too hard to energize and reinvent itself.  Each year, we have a couple of big episodes that each will spin the show in a new direction in terms of the character arcs.   Watching some Scrubs on DVD, I’m reminded of just how often in the past the show did this exactly right.

Which is why the musical episode came off as so wrong.  Again, it’s trying too hard.  Musically, it’s rather sound and the dance numbers all look great.  Technically, there is nothing to fault.  What I do fault is that the numbers were trying too hard to be funny.  Also, to go back to Buffy, the musical palate of Buffy was very broad, allowing for a vareity of musical styles to suit the characters and their particular situations.  Here, the musical palatte was a bit too narrow, seeming to be a low-rent version of Rent or Les Mis.  Indeed, the Les Mis roots showed time and again.

The biggest difference–once the Scrubs musical was over, I shrugged, said that’s nice and moved on.  The songs are available for free on iTunes but I’ve not bothered to download them.  Unlike Buffy‘s musical episode where within minutes of the episode going off the air, I scoured the Net to find bootleg copies of the songs and listened to them for weeks, driving friends, family and co-workers crazy.

So, if you want to see a true genius take a musical episode and work magic with it, get to season six, disc two of Buffy.   If you want to see a musical episode that is nice but just trying too hard, watch Scrubs.

Posted in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Scrubs | No Comments »

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

  • free short keys of computer
  • eagle eyes pc
  • update mcafee oas
  • mgk wild boy download video
  • clique kanye west zippy
  • j cole balance download
  • the killers abbey road
  • bubble bobble for mac
  • download ringtones jonas brothers
  • dj max fever iso
  • blazblue continuum shift extend pc
  • mupen64 plus windows
  • 7 days video by m.i
  • download eyes rogue wave mp3
  • download song mitran nu shonk hathyaran da
  • download end of you mimesis
  • papuri singers mp3 download
  • camp rock 1 free
  • acrobat standard 9 download free
  • friendly fires 2008
  • proxy for linux
  • download happy tree friends theme song
  • kon boot version 1.1
  • download album tomis junior vol 5
  • quicktime mozilla plugin
  • live cd ubuntu free
  • vob player 2.0 download
  • sierra home architect free
  • how to absinthe 2.0.5
  • pt 3.6 firefox
  • ozzy osbourne scream free
  • la vera storia di internet streaming
  • samsung omnia i8910 pc suite
  • download eat right for your type giglio
  • download aliens vs predator pc game
  • depois da meia noite stephen king
  • drawn together season 3 download
  • sathi sakhiya mp3
  • mysql installer for windows 7
  • download bank of america into quickbooks
  • free project 64 roms games
  • us citizenship questions
  • download recorded video from ipod touch
  • download uc browser 8.5.1 for android
  • win 7 loader v1.6.9
  • download ehsaan itna sa kar de from songs.pk
  • diarios do vampiro anoitecer
  • ozzy osbourne budokan cd
  • download old xcode version
  • dark swan 3 iron crowned download
  • not a stain on me remix
  • quark strangeness and charm
  • download shy glizzy new mixtape
  • download numberbook for blackberry mini curve
  • richie campbell my path
  • punisher max 3 download
  • the climb 2002
  • adobe cs3 dreamweaver download
  • sergio mendes brasil 66
  • kk singer song list download
  • internet manager 6.07 with patch
  • bb app world kaskus
  • shook down yuck mp3
  • download the closer season 6
  • tip taps tip halcali download
  • free vdock 3d genesis
  • download lagu terpopuler barat
  • ebook sejarah gelap para paus
  • non stop bhajan download
  • lancelot o primeiro cavaleiro
  • download 18 wos pttm scania highline
  • abhijeet songs tere bina
  • soulmate moving on album download
  • download lg ks360 apps
  • java tm plug in for chrome
  • fable 3 hair
  • lagu andaiku tahu
  • songs of abdul alim
  • tac Aa nhanh nha??t
  • mafia 1 download crack
  • download ray lamontagne this love is over
  • hangover with greek subs
  • free mp3 lingsir wengi kuntilanak
  • akinator il genio del web
  • mcci whql usb modem driver
  • adobe reader 5 free
  • mueve la mano
  • psp 6.39 mb 4
  • tyson's tiger song
  • tudo novo regis danese playback
  • desktop destroyer download game free
  • free download nokia 5310 clock themes
  • download zoids legacy 2 for gba
  • filme julgamento final gratis
  • download surat yasin untuk bb
  • download sonny 1 and 2
  • buku ranah 3 warna gratis
  • free espt ppn 1107 put
  • download trance around the world 394
  • bedava bus driver download
  • grand theft modification for xbox 360
  • vmware mac os x lion
  • download isley brothers at your best
  • justice ultra 2012
  • ebiet g ade terbaru
  • pih dowod rzeczowy nr 1
  • zuma deluxe latest version
  • fundamentos de bioquAmica voet download
  • download the bright lights ep
  • download selalu untuk selamanya
  • lagu ade irma sengsara
  • download willie nelson songs
  • elas mara lima
  • thursday the weeknd
  • andria la dispute mp3 download
  • free of britannica encyclopedia 2010
  • amazon ebooks for kindle
  • the sims 1 zapytaj
  • new breed gary chester download scientifically
  • elv1s 30 #1 hits download
  • download technical communication a principles and practice
  • chief eric church
  • free talking rex the dinosaur
  • bulk pictures from facebook
  • c# como programar ebook download
  • download tvr windows 7
  • camtasia ita gratis
  • lagu kpop boyfriend
  • free webm player for pc
  • aquecimento global dj mandrake
  • sap 7.2 gui
  • groove coverage download album
  • asoka movie 2001
  • free wagner ride of the valkyries
  • download lagu puisi hilang
  • beyblade metal fusion episodes
  • windows xp spanish iso
  • hp 6122 software
  • eeda eeda tamil song
  • velayudham songs free mp3
  • lg c 105 firmware download
  • car wash song free
  • lou bega mambo 5 mp3
  • download world war one footage
  • download 3 ball mty intentalo
  • steam while in game
  • smadav 8.6 key
  • eating out 3
  • fmobi for meego
  • secure client download windows 7 64 bit
  • elena sf 3 mugen download
  • rt theme wordpress free download
  • download vb tutorial muff
  • 6.72 ai 1.1
  • cocorosie lemonade mp3
  • automapa 2011 chomikuj
  • download 3d max 8 keygen
  • hp laserjet p3005 treiber
  • download sleeping at last yearbook collection
  • anatomy trains apricot
  • norton 360 v6 download
  • hafiz abu bakr naats free
  • download rockafeller skank by fatboy slim
  • jogos nokia c6 00
  • l ultimo regalo ita
  • independent woman by destiny's child
  • warzone tower defense extended download
  • moorhuhn kart 1 download vollversion
  • lost hawks andre nickatina mp3
  • lezioni di piano download ita
  • club penguin revolution
  • rebelde dublado 1 temporada
  • filme raul seixas 2011
  • code geass free episodes
  • download mbsa latest version
  • maroon 5 overexposed password
  • tieu ngao giang ho audio download
  • black ops clips
  • quickbooks pos 6.0 download
  • one tree hill 9x08
  • hp psc 1400 printer
  • garmin nuvi 260 software download
  • download breaking dawn myegy
  • movie websites free online
  • download driver compaq cq20 326tu
  • vcenter enterprise converter
  • untouchable hacks for mac